Paul Ryan - Quotes
A troubling pattern is emerging in the quotes from
Paul Ryan. Some of these quotes from
Paul Ryan are half-truths. As shown below, these Paul Ryan quotes are
also hypocritical.
A politician telling half-truths should surprise few, but what makes these quotes
from Paul Ryan matter more than the quotes from other politicians is that Paul Ryan is being touted as the man whose
plan we should trust to solve our
budget and
debt crises. If Paul Ryan cannot be trusted to tell the
truth on small matters, he cannot be entrusted with weightier matters.
For example, in his acceptance speech at the Republican National Convention, Paul Ryan
decried:
"The biggest, coldest power play of all in Obamacare came at the expense of the elderly. ... They just took it all away
from Medicare - $716 billion - funneled out of Medicare by President Obama."
What he didn't mention is that long before Obamacare became law, he - Paul Ryan
- put those same
"$716 billion" of
Medicare
cuts into his budget plan. Moreover, his budget plan has other clauses
aimed at cutting Medicare much more than Obamacare does.
In his Republican National Convention speech, Paul Ryan also criticized
Barack Obama for not heeding
the debt commission's final report:
"[Barack Obama] created a bipartisan debt
commission. They came back with an urgent report. He thanked them, sent them on
their way and then did exactly nothing."
Paul Ryan was a member of that
"bipartisan debt
commission" and actually voted against its final report, so he criticized the President for rejecting what he also rejected.
(For the far more egregious
Mitt
Romney platform quotes,
click here.)
In the same speech, Paul Ryan also blamed
Barack Obama for
the closure of a General Motors plant in his hometown of Janesville, Wisconsin,
lamenting:
"A lot of guys I went to high school with worked at
that GM plant. Right there at that plant, candidate Obama said: 'I believe that
if our government is there to support you ... this plant will be here for
another hundred years.' That's what [Barack Obama] said in 2008. Well, as it
turned out, that plant didn't last another year."
That GM plant closed in late 2008, before
Barack Obama took office in
2009. Since Paul Ryan resides in Janesville and,
"a lot of guys I went to high
school with worked at that GM plant," he cannot claim ignorance of the plant's closure date.
In 2009, while decrying the economic stimulus as government cronyism, Paul Ryan
wrote at least four letters to Energy Secretary Stephen Chu asking for stimulus
money to be given to companies that contributed to his political campaign,
including Wisconsin Energy Conservation Corporation that eventually received
$20 million.
But in 2010, Paul Ryan told Boston's WBZ Radio that he,
"did not ask for stimulus money," declaring,
"I'm not one who votes for something and then writes to the government to ask
them to send us money." For the next two years, Paul Ryan maintained
this. In early August 2012, he repeated in a television interview with WCPO Cincinnati,
"I never asked for stimulus."
When confronted with evidences that he had written the aforementioned letters asking for stimulus money, Paul Ryan
quietly issued a
statement on August 16, 2012 conceding,
"After having these letters called to my
attention I checked into them. ... They should have been handled better, and I
take responsibility for that."
Two weeks later, he neither took responsibility nor mentioned his own pursuit of
the stimulus money when he decried in his Republican National Convention speech:
"The stimulus was a case of political patronage,
corporate welfare and cronyism at their worst. You, the working men and women of
this country, were cut out of the deal."
Was he accusing himself of engaging in
"political
patronage, corporate welfare and cronyism at their worst," or hoping that
the national audience remains largely unaware of his own admission just two
weeks earlier?
Even on subjects unrelated to politics, Paul Ryan has shown a tendency
to bend the truth.
For example, when questioned about his physical fitness, Paul Ryan told Hugh Hewitt Radio
on August 22, 2012 that he doesn't
"run
marathons anymore," adding,
“I was fast when
I was younger," and boasted that he used to finish marathons in,
“under three [hours], high twos. I had a two hour
and fifty-something.”
After being confronted with the truth, Paul Ryan has
since admitted that he
has run only one marathon in his life and took over 4 hours to finish it.